1. Home
  2. Troubleshooting
  3. Managing a failed block
TROUBLESHOOTING

Managing a failed block

Why peripheral nerve blocks fail, how to prevent it, how to test a block, and what to do step by step when it is not working.

DRAFT · AWAITING CLINICAL REVIEW

About one peripheral nerve block in ten does not give the effect that was planned. A block has failed when it does not give the expected anaesthesia or analgesia in a reasonable time, so the operation cannot go ahead comfortably without something extra: another block, systemic analgesia, sedation or a general anaesthetic. Most failures can be prevented, and the rest can be managed safely with a plan agreed before the procedure.

Why blocks fail, and how to prevent it

ProblemHow to reduce it
The patient
Anxiety, language or hearing barriersExplain the plan clearly, give a leaflet, use an interpreter, and agree a back-up plan during consent.
Obesity or sarcopeniaChoose a shallower block (for example axillary rather than supraclavicular), a lower-frequency probe, and add nerve stimulation if unsure. Ask an experienced colleague.
Hard to position (arthritis, contractures)Pick a block that suits the position the patient can manage, and use supports.
Reduced response to local anaesthetic (for example Ehlers–Danlos syndrome)Ask about it in the history and expect a weaker or shorter block.
Anatomical variationPre-scan, and trace each nerve proximally and distally before injection. The plexus or a branch may lie in an unusual place.
The operation
Surgical plan changes (longer incision, different approach, longer operation)Discuss the area the block will cover at the team brief, and ask the surgeon to communicate any change of plan.
Tourniquet painExpect it 30 to 60 minutes after inflation. Cover the tourniquet site (for example intercostobrachial infiltration for a high arm tourniquet) and have a plan to treat it.
The anaesthetist and equipment
Early in the learning curveHave senior help on hand. A block room with time and good ergonomics helps.
Unfamiliar ultrasound machine or needleCheck the machine, probe, preset, depth and gain before starting, and use the right needle.
Wrong local anaesthetic, or not enough timeChoose a drug and volume that last long enough for the operation, and allow time for onset before testing.

Before you start

Equipment
Machine charged and plugged in, correct needle (length, gauge, echogenic), injection pressure monitor if used.
Ergonomics
Table at the correct height, with the operator, block site and screen in line.
Assistant
Briefed on the plan, the drug and the volume.
Prep, stop, block
Mark the side, and stop to check it again just before the needle goes in.
Picture
Pre-scan, right probe and preset, depth and gain. Use PART (pressure, alignment, rotation, tilt) and colour Doppler to find vessels.
Spread
Watch the local anaesthetic spread around the nerve or along the plane. Spread along the nerve, rather than one small pool, predicts success.

Testing the block

Allow sufficient time before testing: the time to onset depends on the drug, the block and the patient. Changes appear in this order: sympathetic (warm, dry skin), then sensory (cold and pinprick), then motor. Compare with the other side. A warm limb is an early, useful sign, and if the patient came in with pain, relief of that pain is encouraging.

Arm: ask the patient to…Tests
Shoulder abductionAxillary
First 15° of abduction; external rotationSuprascapular
Elbow flexionMusculocutaneous
Wrist and elbow extension, supination: open hand, 'paper'Radial
Thumb opposition, finger and wrist flexion: fist, 'rock'Median
Finger spreading, thumb adduction: 'scissors'Ulnar
Leg: ask the patient to…Tests
Hip flexion, knee extensionFemoral
Hip adductionObturator
Knee flexionSciatic
Ankle plantar flexion, foot inversion, toe flexionTibial
Foot eversionSuperficial peroneal
Ankle dorsiflexion, toe extensionDeep peroneal

Weakness of the movement suggests that nerve is blocked. For skin areas, use the body map.

Managing a failing block in an awake patient

  1. Block not ready, surgery not started

    • Give it more time, then test again nerve by nerve.
    • If one nerve is missed, a rescue block of that nerve further along its course may work: ulnar, median or radial in the arm; femoral, popliteal sciatic or ankle nerves in the leg.
    • Before any rescue block, add up all the local anaesthetic already given. Stay under the maximum dose.
    • Or ask the surgeon to infiltrate, again within the total dose.
  2. Surgery has started and the patient is uncomfortable

    • Ask the surgeon to pause. Find out if it is pain, or anxiety and discomfort.
    • Anxiety or discomfort without pain: reassure, and offer light conscious sedation.
    • Tourniquet pain: consider low-dose ketamine (about 0.1 mg/kg) or sedoanalgesia; ask the surgeon whether the tourniquet can be let down.
    • Surgical pain: a short-acting opioid can provide analgesia while a decision is made.
    • Never treat pain with sedation alone.
  3. Pain from the operation persists

    • If the local anaesthetic maximum has not been reached: surgical infiltration or a top-up block.
    • If the maximum has been reached, or the top-up fails: convert to general anaesthesia with systemic analgesia.
    • If general anaesthesia is not safe for this patient: stop and abandon the operation. Discuss this possibility at consent.

Rescue blocks and top-ups, safely

  • Agree plan B (rescue block, sedation, general anaesthesia, or stopping) during consent, before the block.
  • Use the dose calculator to add every dose given, including the surgeon's infiltration. A repeat dose of bupivacaine needs a gap of hours, and the total must stay within the daily limit.
  • A rescue block placed below a partly working block may be in numb skin: the patient cannot report paraesthesia from needle–nerve contact. Use an injection pressure monitor or nerve stimulator, and go slowly.
  • Avoid blocks in an anaesthetised or deeply sedated adult where possible. Rescue blocks under drapes are harder: plan the position.
  • Deeper rescue blocks carry more risk of hitting a vessel. Aspirate, inject slowly in small amounts, and watch for signs of toxicity.
  • Tell the patient what happened, and document what was missed and the actions taken.

Open the dose calculatorAdd up every dose before a top-up. If toxicity is suspected, follow the LAST protocol.

The failed nerve catheter

  1. Read the block record: which catheter, how deep at the skin, which drug and rate.
  2. Ask and examine: is the failure new? Is it complete or patchy? Is there a new cause of pain, such as compartment syndrome or a tight cast?
  3. Check the equipment: pump running, line connected, no leaks, the right bag.
  4. Look at the catheter mark at the skin. Slipping out is the most common cause. Secure with glue and a clear dressing.
  5. Give a bolus and test again. If the block returns, the catheter is still in the right place.
  6. If unsure, scan over the catheter tip while injecting a little saline (colour Doppler shows the spread).
  7. If it still does not work: re-site it, or change to another form of analgesia.

More on infusions and ward care: Nerve catheters. Back to Troubleshooting.

Based on: Bottomley T, Gadsden J, West S. The failed peripheral nerve block. BJA Education 2023;23:92–100. A guide for trained clinicians: follow your local guidelines, and call for senior help early.